Plato’s analogy of
the cave can be related to everyone in many different ways, such example is my
own experience toward another person. A
few years back, I firmly believed that I can help people out by trying my best
to encourage them reach their goal. When
I was still in community college and fresh out of high school, I always had the
dream that I would continue my schooling with one of my close friends, Mr.
K. Mr. K had shown interest in attending
collage but did not have as strong the desire to go as I did. I thought that hleping him out would help him get his
act together. What had ended up
happening was that I would give Mr. K rides from his house to school. As time passed, he ended up quitting going to
classes, and for years I had put my own education to a slower pace in order to get
him to go. However, the results would
always be fruitless. I had always
thought that I could get him to go to school but later on i realized that the
end result will always be the same and that I cannot change him and the only
person that would change him would be himself.
In the end, I had no choice but to quit on him and shifted the focus
more on my own studies. I would only hope that in the future Mr. K will change
his way of thinking.
I can relate several of Plato’s
symbols in his allegory cave to my experience with my friend. Starting off with the idea of the cave, I
think that I was the one in that cave since I was so confident in getting Mr. K
back to school but ended up failing, and my shadow would be my ego as it got
the best of me saying that I can be the one that can get him back to school and
so I became my own prisoner. The
puppeteer would be myself since I let myself be convinced that I can help my
friend out. When I was exposed to the
things that I’ve been doing I realized that all those efforts I have put into
helping him never worked, and this path I took prevented me from going forward with my own life. I was blinded by the fact that I could make a
difference in Mr. K’s life and by giving
up on him brought me sadness and pain knowing that nothing will change¸ leaving
him to his self-destruction. Knowing
gave me a sense of freedom, and the things Mr. K did give me was the
realization of things I should not do in life and I would try to avoid what he
has done so I can move on. In the end I
have to return knowing the fact that my friend would always be the same and the
only way for him to change is by helping him help his own self.
This is a very insightful story Fred, and the realization you came to is quite profound. Your statement that you became a prisoner of your own cave is a succinct one, and it could make for an excellent essay topic. Your second movie choice "I Heart Huckabees" explores this phenomenon in a very interesting and enlightening way. Both Albert and Brad (the protagonist and antagonist of the story) are completely trapped within their own minds and egos, and they both get those egos shattered by how they disappoint not simply the people they are close to and responsible for, but themselves as well. I would greatly enjoy talking over this subject with you, let me know if you'd like to do so during office hours.
ReplyDeleteyeah i will take on I Heard Huckabees
ReplyDelete